Tuesday, December 4, 2012


Had Bob Hope's plane crashed into the Atlantic as he was flying to the UK to film The Iron Petticoat in 1956, his place in show business would have been assured. No less a personage than Woody Allen named Hope his favorite comedian, and the one he emulated when he started doing stand-up. (And what are Bananas, Sleeper and Love and Death if not Bob Hope comedies for a with-it crowd?)
Trust me, this is how you
want to remember him.

To watch Hope in his prime -- roughly 1940 to 1952 -- is a pleasure few funnymen can offer. With his impeccable
delivery,  pleasant singing voice and surprisingly agreeable soft-shoe dancing style, Hope was a comedic actor of the first order. Had history taken a different turn, UCLA would be holding retrospectives in his honor. Comedy classes would teach "The Hope Style."  Perhaps there would be an honorary "Bob Hope Award" given each year at the Academy Awards for the most deserving comedic actor.

Fortunately for his family but not the rest of us, Hope arrived at Heathrow Airport safe and sound to start his 47-year freefall into mediocrity and beyond. It was an experience both Hope and co-star Katherine Hepburn would eventually pretend never happened. If only.

These two aren't nearly as
uncomfortable with each other as
you'll be when watching The Iron Petticoat.
Pretty much a rip-off of Greta Garbo's superior Ninotchka, The Iron Petticoat tells the story of Major Chuck Lockwood's (Hope) attempt to "flip" Soviet flyer Captain Vinka Kovelenko (Hepburn) when she unexpectedly lands her fighter jet on an American military base in Germany. Her reason for landing is either because she was angry at getting passed over for a promotion, or to flip the guy who was going to be her handler. I couldn't tell because Hepburn's Russian accent is so thick that I couldn't make out what she was saying and, after only five minutes into the movie, I couldn't bother to rewind the DVR. 

Lockwood would rather go on leave to visit his rich aristocratic fiancee. But in no time, Chuck and Vinka fall in love. And when Soviet spies arrest Vinka for treason, Chuck risks his life to rescue her. When he's captured, too, they're taken to the USSR
-- only to be treated as national heroes while the Russian spies are arrested for... well, again, I'm not sure. By this time, I was just waiting for THE END to appear so I could say that I watched The Iron Petticoat and survived.

Where to begin? Well, you can blame the script, but that's a tricky thing. Ben Hecht, who wrote the original version of the screenplay, was no hack. He and his former writing partner, Charles MacArthur, were responsible for The Front Page, one of the all-time great Broadway shows, as well as two of the most underrated movies of the 1930s, The Scoundrel and Crime Without Passion. Hecht wrote The Iron Petticoat specifically for Katherine Hepburn. It might have made a fine movie for she and Spencer Tracy, but Ol' Ski Nose got his fingerprints on it first. Or rather, his gag writers' fingerprints.

Kate thanks Bob between takes
for his contributions to the movie.
And thereby lays the problem. Hope's great movies were written for him. No matter who he was playing -- Chester Hooten, Orville "Turkey" Jackson, Hotlips Barton, Monsieur Beaucaire -- he was always Bob Hope, Comedian. (The exceptions were The Seven Little Foys and Beau James, but those were straight biopics.)  One-liners that might have worked elsewhere drop like Wurlitzers off a rooftop. (When he asks a Russian with a large fur hat, "Who does your hair?", your first thought is Why did he say that?) His response to a spy who calls him "dog nose" -- "Oh, so you've got Crosby blood in you" -- not only makes no sense in context of the film, but calls attention to just what was wrong in hiring Hope to begin with. His dated references to Estes Kefauver and the like further harm the movie. Hecht's script -- presuming the gag writers didn't touch anyone else's dialogue -- isn't perfect to begin with. A cliched Southern senator and some badly-directed slapstick with the Soviet spies aren't as funny as they might have appeared on paper. But without a doubt, Hope's awful one-liners further spoil an already questionable brew.

Bob turns to drink when discovering
he has to pick up the check.
You can bet your silver nitrate print of Road to Rio that Hope's gagmen  didn't get a bonus for working overtime on The Iron Petticoat. As John McElwee put it on his Greenbriar Picture Shows site, "Bob used his writers like Kleenex, but underpaid loyally for those many years they toiled in the vineyards."

Katherine Hepburn is game, but dialect comedy isn't her forte. Her stern looks certainly resemble those of a Russian officer, and she actually looks good in her military uniform. But once she switches to "capitalistic" feminine items -- negligees, gowns, lacy underwear -- she's, frankly, unattractive. Maybe it's the fashions of the day, maybe it's the fact that Hepburn was never particularly feminine to begin with. Whatever it is, it puts to lie, as do her movies with Spencer Tracy, the idea of Hepburn as an icon for liberation. Because by the final reel in these movies, all she wants to do is give up her career and make breakfast for hubby. And in The Iron Petticoat, she wants to do it in Indianapolis, Indiana for no better reason than Hecht thought it would sound funny in a Russian accent.

Really, don't you want to slap him silly?

The Iron Petticoat also marks, I believe, a major turning point for Hope, one that forever changed how he regarded his audience. His once ingratiatingly sly grin transforms here to a permanently contemptuous sneer. It's as if he's telling us, This might be crap but I don't care -- I'm Bob Hope, and you'll take whatever I dish out. How wrong he was.

No matter what language,
The Iron Petticoat is appalling.
Despite The Iron Petticoat's flaws, Ben Hecht had an otherwise good track record and a reputation to go with it. Once he saw what happened to his script, he demanded, quite loudly in the press, that his name be removed from the credits in its American release. 

Neither Hope, Hepburn nor critics were happy with the result. Hope, in fact, pulled the movie from circulation in the mid-60s, while Hepburn never mentioned it again. That TCM helped to recently engineer The Iron Petticoat's first TV airing in well over 40 years (the original British print, with Hecht's writing credit intact) was something of a coup. But as we saw with Russia, coups aren't always what they're cracked up to be.

Bob Hope winds up
his career in The Road to Zombieville.
Katherine Hepburn's career wasn't tarnished by this ungodly waste of celluloid. But, like the curse it was, The Iron Petticoat marked the beginning of the final, unfortunate phase of Bob Hope's career. With the exception of the aforementioned Beau James, there was nothing ahead but sitcomish movies, retreads of earlier hits and, more than anything else, a futile desire to remain the light romantic leading man of yore. (Near the end of his career, he was playing 35 year-olds while in his 70s.)

His TV specials were even worse, with titles like Bob Hope's Pink Panther Thanksgiving Gala. And his writers were still force-feeding increasingly stale jokes into pathetic scripts hoping for foie gras. What ultimately emerged at the other end, instead, was something far more odious.


No comments: